Automatic Eyeliner

Color is beautiful and it definitely stays but I'm having the hardest time getting this on my waterline. It either doesn't stick or rubs off whatever I'm getting to stick. Also when I did get it to stick my eye started to hurt. I rubbed it on my hand to warm it up and the tip broke off. So I'm not really happy with it so far.

I love jeffrees products and have been a customer for years. This is the first time I ever had an issue. Eyeliner is definitely not perfected. It fell out in multiple broken chunks. Completely unusable. I put the chunks back in and tried to see if I could use it, color doesn’t even show up on eye. Don’t waste your money.

Received today in the UK and couldn't wait to use, took lid off and the eyeliner came flying out. Shall see if can heat it and get it to stick back. Stunning colour but so tiny and obviously very fragile.

This eyeliner is a beautiful color. My issue is , both times I used it the tio broke off. When it was applying it just made a mess of itself. I was super gentle with it and it just turned into a creamy mess. I’m done with his products. Boy bye

This is the first JSC product I've ever had to return. Honestly, I expected more. They're hard, don't go over shadows, don't stay on the water line, and they're dry. Just save your money and don't bother with these.

This new liner by Jeffree Star is amazing. It is so smudge-proof it hurts. Very long-wearing and the colour I got is amazing. Armored Truck has a great green shift to it. I highly recommend these new liners!

This is a beautiful color I just wish the formula wasn't so I dont know fragile and crumbly. its a bit dry too and hard to get on the water line. Its very hard to get it to go on without breaking.

I have to say that this was the most nicest packaging that I ever gotten for an eyeliner. Upon the first time using. It was very creamy to the eyes. But I had a hard time trying to get the product on my waterline. It would stay on my lashes but I could not get it into where I really wanted. The pencil has not broke on me yet. But the product does get on your fingers and nose...whoops! Due to its creaminess. It can get on you a bit easily. The product does stay on pretty well. And it doesn’t smear away. So the quality is good!

If you do a swatch on your hand and put it to the light, the reflection is pretty. But when you come to put it on your eye, it breaks easily and doesn't apply unless you pass several times. Dollar store makes better eyeliners

Beautiful color, but the first time I used it a chunk broke off. I was able to use this 4 times before it got completely stuck in the tube. No amount of twisting will get it out. Complete waste of money.