The Classic

Found it to be easy to apply and the color is not too dark or to light. Perfect for every day or evening. Went on smooth and stayed on nicely. I have thus far tried many of Charlottes make up and her wonderful skin care and could not be more satisfied.

I don't normally wear eyeliner much because my eyes tend to water, but our in-house MUA recommended that I try Charlotte's Classic pencils, which has a powdery formulation (as opposed to a liquid formulation). She suggested that it would be a good one to try with my watery eyes. It glides on beautifully (I find stiff eyeliner pencils are unbearable) and has held up well! The ease with which it goes on helps it look great, since you can really work it around while its still moveable. I might become an eyeliner convert!

I had high expectations for for this eyeliner after having such a fantastic experience with Charlotte's rock n kohl liner. Sadly, this is a miss for me. I've tried it multiple times and it lasts about 15 minutes before completely disappearing. I do not have particularly oily eyelids and I do not tend to have this problem with other brands of eyeliner. It is a soft powdery looking pencil and I hoped I'd love it, but it just does not seem to be a good formula for me.

I kinda feel like the lip and eye pencils might be the jewels in the CT brand crown, thanks to the great colors, not too soft / not too hard perfect consistency, and doing what they're supposed to do. I used The Classic for a project where I needed a liner that was going to stay without smearing and smudging through long days shooting on the beach, and this one pulled that off with no issues. <3

Like chocolate ! This eyeliner is amazing. It is soft, but precise. It stays on until I take it off. Great for tight lining. I have around 30 eyeliners and this is my go to liner. I just ordered two more so I won't ever be without it!

I am all about the smudgy-liner and taupe brown eyeshadow looks and this pencil is so great! Like many mentioned, it's not as intense as her Rock N Kohl's but it provides the 'soft focus' effect which I really love. You can definitely intensify this for night.

Personally, I like to line my eyeshadows with a dark brown/black eyeshadow and then use the liner to tight line and then line it really closely to my lash line and do a tiny flick (CT style!) and smudge it a tiny bit. And, add some on the bottom.

The effect is so beautiful and exactly what I'm looking for. It doesn't smudge on me and stays on pretty well. I hear it's comparable to Tom Ford's Espresso pencil.

Do not put this on your waterline! This is a powder pencil! On that note I do love it for a not too harsh everyday line look that makes my lashes look fuller and very natural. I wish charlotte had put the name on the pencil itself, but it can be forgiven.

This eyeliner applies smoothly and with ease. I love it every time I use it and its never too much or too little.. just perfect

I thought that the CT Rock 'n Kohl eyeliner was the best eyeliner I've ever purchased, but this is my new favourite, so much that I'll be buying back-ups just in case. This is a buttery smooth eyeliner that glides on effortlessly and is very pigmented. I use it for tightlining and therefore don't smudge it, but if you wanted to, it smudges quite easily after application, otherwise it holds a defined line very well.

The reason this has surpassed the Rock 'n Kohl eyeliner (which I also use for tightlining) is that I live in a very hot and humid climate, and while the Rock 'n Kohl is a million times better than most, it still "melts" a little in the heat over the course of the day and I can end up with panda eyes if it gets too hot. Not so with the Classic. I'm a convert!

Comparing the liquid eyeliner, l prefer this for the daily make-up look. It is subtle, easy to draw, can draw it very precisely. So awesome! I'm a big fan of Charlotte and got most of the products here, love it. What can l say. And great shopping here the shipment is so fast which l can enjoy my stuff earlier as l expected!